Ben Aris: Europe writes itself out of Ukraine talks | Matthew Blackburn: Is Europe starting to come to its senses on Ukraine?

By Ben Aris, Substack, 10/28/26

Europe has written itself out of any role in the talks to end the war in Ukraine and, despite an enormous amount of bluster, has become totally irrelevant.

Finnish President Alexander Stubb and Norwegian Prime Minister Jonas Gahr Store called Vladimir Putin yesterday [10/27] – only the second time a European leader has talked to Putin since the start of the war (if you count the Kremlin allies Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico and Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban out of the list).

The first was French President Emmanuel Macron who talked to him last year, but admitted that he got nothing out of the conversation. Quelle surprise!

Sounds like the two Nords did get much further: the call was scheduled to last 20mins but instead they got an hour-long history lecture from Putin – who always does this and it predates the war as he did the same to Merkel when she was negotiating the Minsk I agreement. Turker Carlson was subject to the same lesson about “Vlad the Great” when he interviewed Putin – the big man clearly has a bee in his bonnet on Central European history and Russia’s right to whatever it wants.

Put another way: they didn’t talk about how to end the war.

More poignantly: this was not a negotiation or even an attempt to start peace talks.

That is not the reported substance of Putin’s conversation with Witkoff a week ago. At least Witkoff put some sort of deal on the table, even if Yuri Ushakov, Putin’s top foreign policy advisor, later said it didn’t contain much of interest to the Kremlin. However, since then there are reports now of the US going into business with Russia in oil and the Trump administration is also clearly interested in taking the Nord Stream pipeline over. So, that was a real conversation.

The call highlights how completely irrelevant the EU is in this whole saga other than wrecking its economy and emptying its own arsenal. Norway isn’t even a member of the EU. The Kremlin made it explicitly clear that it will not talk to the EU and both Nords were invited on the basis of being “neighbourly” countries. Stubb repeated this formula in his read out of the meeting. You can tell when Putin has someone by the balls as they trot out some Kremlin catch phrase when they want to butter him up. It used to be a single market “from Lisbon to Vladivostok” but I haven’t heard that one for years.

And the meeting also highlighted the growing disunity in the EU on the Russia question. Now serious talks are on again, the EU is having another go at finding someone to act as interlocutor. Stubb is a leading candidate (but I still think Schoeder should be a contender). However, the boys were immediately roasted by Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen, a leading Russian hawk, for even deigning to talk to VVP.

Of course, if Europe was really serious about opening discussions with Putin, the two to go are European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas, but it’s crystal clear that the Kremlin will refuse to talk to either one. Indeed, the Kremlin has already said that it will reject any suggestions originating in Brussels out of hand.

And Kallas is so rabidly anti-Russian that even her colleagues are unhappy with her “foreign policies.”

She says bonkers things every time she stands in front of a mic and her whole plan is to “increase the pressure on Russia” until it eventually collapses and breaks into pieces. And then she oversees a process that gutted the 21st sanctions package by including a carve out that allows Greek tankers to continue to work for Russia’s shadow fleet. No wonder Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy is starting to look desperate. She has become an embarrassment to the institution and even internally she appears to have been completely sidelined as if a real but extremely delicate process does begin, her clumsy approach would almost certainly run it off the tracks.

The more subtle point here is that the Kremlin hates dealing with multinational bodies, but the EU first and foremost. It is like bilateral talks as you can prey on national interests in two-way talks but can’t when any deal you suggest has to be approved by committee.

Tellingly the end of the phone call discussed security issues in the Baltics, where presumably Putin offered some trinkets to entice the Fins in particular; as IntelliNews reported, the Finnish economy has been cut to tatters by the bust up with Russia – worse even than the damage done to Germany.

Was the call progress? Call me cynical (with a lot of justification) but all I saw was more political kabuki. The Nords have nothing to offer. The Kremlin has a chance to show “we are not the problem” – a game that both Putin and Zelenskiy are playing at the moment – and nothing was agreed. Stubb and Store are not even the right people. It should have been von der Leyen and/or Kallas on that call and they have been ruled out from the start.

Like I said before this round of talks are “highly likely,” as the West loves to say, doomed to failure.

***

Here’s a different take:

Is Europe starting to come to its senses on Ukraine?

By Matthew Blackburn, Responsible Statecraft, 10/27/26

The Trump administration’s latest initiative to end the war is creating heartburn in Europe.

“We have to pressure the aggressor to stop the war, not the victim to surrender,” said European Union High Representative Kaja Kallas. “Squeezing Ukraine is not the right approach, and that’s why Europe is standing by Ukraine.” Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, meanwhile, insists Russia has no genuine desire for peace, pointing in particular to Russian strikes on Ukrainian civilians.

This moral language frames the conflict as a zero-sum, good-versus-evil struggle. In this light, Europeans have no choice but to unite behind Ukraine to stop Russian President Vladimir Putin.

But not all European leaders are talking this way. The press conference in Oslo on Oct. 20 featuring Zelenskyy, Norwegian Prime Minister Jonas Gahr Støre and Finnish President Alexander Stubb was full of constructive language about ending the conflict. Stubb said the Oslo summit was the result of “substantive progress” made “under the radar.” Støre emphasised that “Europe has to be at the table” to secure a “lasting peace.” Europe, it seems, is not united on a negotiated end to the conflict.

Then on Tuesday, the two held a call with Putin unofficially, in an effort at de-escalation, according to reports. “We are neighboring countries to Russia,” Stubb said in a statement afterwards. “The outcome of this war will have a direct impact on our and the broader European security. Ending the war requires direct discussions.”

The Oslo summit was no bolt from the blue; Finnish and Norwegian representatives have been preparing the ground for several months. At last week’s Warsaw Security Forum, Norwegian Foreign Minister Espen Barth Eide avoided the usual binary of Ukraine’s victory or capitulation. He stressed that since the Europeans are now paying for the war, they should also lead the diplomacy to end it. Eide noted that a peace agreement could secure a democratic, independent Ukraine integrated into the EU with 80% of its original territory. Advancing this point among more hawkish European colleagues, Eide struck a tone of hope rather than fear. In an interview last Saturday, Eide noted that Europe must contribute concrete proposals for a post-war security architecture: “in the long run, we need to return to a normal relationship with Russia after the war (….) some kind of order must be restored.”

During his recent visit to the Norwegian Institute of International Affairs, Stubb presented a complementary argument. Restating his case for a “value-based realism,” he argued that European states should be faithful to their values but would not resolve the conflict by rigidly clinging to the moral high ground. Stubb urged the audience to keep “cooler heads”; fostering a “war mentality” would make it near impossible to conceive of peace.

Eide and Stubb are moving in a different direction from those who claim “victory” over Russia – however defined – is a prerequisite for future European security. They reject the mantra of ex-NATO Secretary General Stoltenberg that “weapons are the way to peace” and emphasize the military reality that neither side has the resources to win decisively.

This is a noble recognition of reality. Offensive actions from both sides have repeatedly failed to produce a breakthrough. Costs keep rising for both warring parties, while gains have become increasingly meagre. Europe, Ukraine, and Russia are stuck in a war that cannot be won on the terms set by either side.

Continuing the current course brings problems for all sides. Putin faces an overheating economy and increasing social fatigue and anxiety. Even if Russia destroys more and more Ukrainian infrastructure from the air, land offensives are likely to incur heavy losses. Ukraine’s situation is even tougher. Its chronic manpower shortages have led to intensified forced mobilization and increased social strains. Blockaded at sea and bombarded from the air, Ukraine is also short of money and weapons, constantly appealing to Western allies to plug the gaps.

The European coalition behind Ukraine faces serious problems of its own. Many European states are facing a sovereign debt crisis as war costs mount. The EU has been unable to persuade Belgium to make use of Russia’s frozen assets to fund the war. All the while, the dirty reality is that, since the war began, Europe has spent more on Russian energy imports than on weapons for Ukraine.

At the same time, Ukraine’s campaign of intensified deep strikes on Russia – supported by the Europeans and greenlit by the Trump Administration in spring 2026 – has failed to pressure Putin into a ceasefire. Without U.S. intelligence and weapons supplies, Europe lacks the military leverage to continue this effort on its own. There is no viable European war plan, only reactive crisis management and ad hoc solutions about Ukraine, coupled with repeated hyping of Russia’s “hybrid war” threat.

Tuesday’s meeting in Oslo provides a way out of this mess. As Stubb said at Tuesday’s press conference: “Peace requires patience. But unfortunately, war does not wait. People are dying each and every day. Our job is to do what we can to end it.” Norway and Finland are communicating the urgency of ending a senseless war. Referring to the recent spat between Trump and Zelensky, Støre advised against dwelling on past disagreements: “What matters now is what lies ahead of us.”

On the same day, Kaja Kallas looked back in anger. She accused the Trump administration of trying to “push Ukraine into surrender” on “Putin’s terms.” Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen, for her part, presented Ukraine as Europe’s only protection: “If we allow Ukraine to fall, we will open the way for Russia to advance into other parts of Europe.”

One can understand fears that, if Ukraine is rendered neutral with limits on its armed forces, Russia would hold the whip hand over Europe. Nobody wants to let Moscow dictate the terms of the European security architecture through violence. But at this point, Europe’s rejection of a “dirty deal” could mean impotently watching Ukraine’s destruction over the next six months. How would this outcome improve European security or prestige?

Norway and Finland have offered the most constructive European response to U.S. diplomacy since Trump returned to the White House. They offer Europe a new language of patient diplomacy to replace maximalist rhetoric. This is in line with both countries’ previous experience mediating and building bridges with Russia. It also recognizes a basic fact: all protracted wars not settled decisively on the battlefield — which is to say, the vast majority of wars — end in negotiated settlements between the aggressor and the defender. America’s signature is absolutely necessary to secure such an outcome.

Mainstream analysis seems unable to accept these realities. It is stuck in moral posturing or fearmongering. There is still little serious discussion of what compromises might be struck. The 28-point plan that U.S.-Russian diplomacy developed in 2025 should not be equated with Ukraine’s capitulation, nor is it a recipe for turning Ukraine into Belarus. Ukraine would enter the EU, receive reconstruction assistance, and retain armed forces on a level comparable to Finland’s. It is time to return to the core points on which a deal must be struck.

Russia has responded positively to the proposals sent from Oslo. Ukraine, Russia, and the U.S. have agreed to a three-way summit in November, according to Zelensky. The key question now is whether other European governments will take the Oslo initiative seriously and agree on who can represent Europe in these talks. Dmitri Peskov, Putin’s press secretary, has cautiously welcomed the idea that Alexander Stubb could represent Europe in the negotiations.

Finland and Norway’s more moderate language is a crucial first step toward a shared European understanding that continuing the war in its current form is self-defeating. As Eide observed at the U.N. last month, “diplomacy can work – if we allow it to.”

But first, Europe must decide: will it support or sabotage the U.S. effort to build a diplomatic off-ramp?

5 thoughts on “Ben Aris: Europe writes itself out of Ukraine talks | Matthew Blackburn: Is Europe starting to come to its senses on Ukraine?”

  1. Regarding the Tucker Carlson Putin interview, Tucker’s interview style is absurd with his interruptions, abrupt changes of subject, lack of depth, etc.. Putin knew this was Tucker’s style and chose to respond in a way that we can say was ineffective. Putin seemed to think he was speaking to a Russian audience, but in fact his audience was global in that moment. Specifically there were 7 target audiences to Putin needed to speak to with these messages:

    (1) to the NATO elite – You will not succeed in your violent effort to weaken and destabilize Russia. We will stop when we are completely satisfied that Ukraine has been de-militarized, de-nazified, and neutralized by facts on the ground – as you say – rather than words on paper much less in the air, since you cannot be trusted to adhere to signed agreements, as we’ve judged from the experience of NATO expansion in spite of promises made to Gorbachev and Yeltsin, and from the Minsk Accords. Russia will not be crushed by the more than 18,000 sanctions which have already been imposed on us. Our economy and financial position is sound, even if you abuse your control of global financial architecture to confiscate our central bank assets, which would be a great mistake on your part. It seems that you prefer a violent unjust unipolar world under your control rather than a multi-polar world at peace. We Russians cannot understand the willingness of European governments to cede sovereignty to the EU and beyond that to America, the chief beneficiary of this conflict with the destruction of Nordstream. Russia is a part of Europe. Our medieval princess Anne of Kiev became the Queen of France, and her descendants were important leaders in many great European. It is easy to see why America has always opposed the strengthening of ties between Europe and Russia. Positive relations between Russia and Europe lead to our mutual prosperity.

    (2) Western governments – you are hypocritical, you have double standards, and you ignore or selectively adhere to international law. The American demand for hegemony according to its own so-called rules-based order is applied based on whether or not America and western interests are advanced. Think about what you did in Serbia, Libya, Syria, and especially Iraq. For example, by what international law are uninvited American forces occupying Syria?

    (3) citizens of the collective West – your governments and media are lying to you continually and suppressing information about the true state of affairs between Russia and Ukraine.

    (4) to the people of the Global South (non-West) – at the core of the American demand for hegemony, this demand to effectively rule the world in your own interests, is the desire of the West to export its irreligious, non-traditional, unnatural, relativistic value system to the rest of the world and undermine your governments and your citizens who are opposed to it.

    (5) to the Ukrainian people – Russia has never intended to conquer or occupy Ukraine. Consider the Minsk2 agreement premised on the Donbas having autonomy within the borders of Ukraine! Even when Minsk failed, Russia greatly limited its support to the Donbas republics between 2014 and 2022 and did not recognize these republics apart from the state of Ukraine. We hoped – in vain as it turns out – that Ukraine would come to its senses, especially after Zelensky was elected in 2019 on promises of peace. It wasn’t until February 2022 that we were compelled to formally recognize the independent Republics of Lugansk and Donetsk. We did this so that we could come to the aid of the citizens of the Donbas and Crimea under the UN Charter’s Responsibility to Protect provision. Compare our 8 years of patience to the US government’s immediate recognition of the new illegal Coup d’Etat anti-Russian regime in Kiev 2014. This is the real smoking gun that proves that Euromaidan was US-instigated and backed. Recall that Ukraine’s ultra-nationalist US-backed leaders prevented a peaceful settlement, insisting on NATO membership and even demanding to have nuclear weapons pointed at Russia. They intended to ethnically-cleanse the Donbas, starting their so-called Anti-Terrorist Operation against their own citizens resulting in more than 13,000 deaths, mostly civilians as a result of indiscriminate shelling into cities by the Ukrainian Armed Forces. Even today, these fascists want to exact revenge on the people of Crimea for choosing to return to Russia after almost 70 years, even to the extent of abusing its control of the Dnieper to empty Crimea’s main water reservoir.

    (6) the current Ukrainian regime – you will be defenestrated and you will not be safe in Lvov.

    (7) to the people of Russia – We did everything we could to avoid our Special Military Operation in Ukraine. We sought a peaceful settlement for 8 long years. But as in the past, America and its allies in Western Europe and elsewhere – the so-called Collective West – continue to see Russia as an enemy, and are determined to vanquish our nation and either turn Russia into their vassal state and failing that to dismember Russia. The West built the Ukrainian army to the 2nd largest in Europe by providing training in the West, including the UAF in NATO’s military exercises, putting NATO advisors into Ukraine, and above all providing crucial intelligence. If we had not gone into Ukraine, they would have continued to pursue this goal relentlessly, and in fact they still do. We have no choice but to defend Russia for the sake of our citizens and our future generations. Our culture, our institutions, our religion life, and our way of life are all at stake. We have determination, strength, and resources to not only withstand, but to defeat this existential threat to the Russian Federation. And above all to restore our peaceful brotherly relationship with Ukraine.

    Putin could have used his Tucker interview to communicate these matters to a global audience, but instead chose to give a history lesson, which is all that interview is remembered for.

  2. I see this note about my previous comment on this essay: “Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview; your comment will be visible after it has been approved.” This is new and interesting, and we’ll see what happens. Nothing I’ve said is offensive in any way except that all of it undermines western propaganda, and could be seen a a pro-Putin apology. But it should be understood as a criticism of Putin’s performance in the Tucker interview and I suggest an approach which I consider to be better, that addresses 7 distinct audiences with the messages that they need to hear. If my commentary is disapproved, and remains unseen, this will say something about the moderator’s propensity to censor. And I’ll have my own little Jacques Baud experience.

    1. The system seems to sometimes do this randomly. Some long time readers who have posted comments before without any moderation gatekeeping will suddenly encounter this. Whenever I get notification of a comment awaiting moderation, I read and almost always approve it. The system is intended to prevent spam from slipping through but sometimes comments get stuck and I can’t figure out what the trigger was.

  3. Thanks Natylies for your reply, and this sets my mind at ease. And thanks for all you do to keep us informed.

    One of items you posted back in March 2022 which kept me tuned into your website was “A Defense Concept for Ukraine” written in 1994 by MIT’s Dr. Barry Posen. It is worth reading again to compare what he wrote against what has unfolded. But the truly remarkable thing is that he wrote this paper (financed by who?) with Russia as the adversary…in 1994. To me, this paper is evidence that the US was planning for this conflict since 1994 or even earlier.

Comments are closed.